GRSM Team Wins Summary Judgment in Million-Dollar HOA Dispute
December 17, 2024 —
Robert A. Bragalone & B. Ryan Fellman - Gordon Rees Scully MansukhaniGordon Rees Scully Mansukhani Partner Bob Bragalone and Senior Counsel Ryan Fellman won a complete summary judgment on behalf of five board members who had been added to an HOA dispute by the defendant homeowners. The GRSM team resolved the matter within just 60 days of taking over the case, bringing an end to a legal battle that had lasted more than four years.
The dispute began when the HOA, as plaintiff, filed suit against the homeowners in Denton County District Court. The HOA alleged that the homeowners had violated the HOA’s Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions by constructing a non-conforming carport and sought a declaratory judgment to resolve the issue. In response, the homeowners filed a counterclaim and third-party petition, adding the individual HOA board members to the lawsuit. They accused the board members—who were serving in a voluntary capacity—of mishandling the dispute and filed claims against them for intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, and gross negligence.
Reprinted courtesy of
Robert A. Bragalone, Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani and
B. Ryan Fellman, Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani
Mr. Bragalone may be contacted at bbragalone@grsm.com
Mr. Fellman may be contacted at rfellman@grsm.com
Read the full story...
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (12/4/24) – Highest Rate of Office Conversions, Lending Caps for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and Affordability Challenges for Homebuyers
December 23, 2024 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, infrastructure-related ballot initiatives, U.S. Green Building Council’s success stories, support for sustainable building, and more!
- 2024 is expected to see the highest rate of office conversions since CBRE began tracking them in 2016. (Nish Amarnath, SmartCities Dive)
- The Federal Housing Finance Agency has established lending caps of $73 billion each for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, allowing them to purchase a total of up to $146 billion in multifamily loans in 2025. (Leslie Shaver, Multifamily Dive)
- A number of infrastructure-related initiatives with the potential to impact facilities managers were on the ballot during the 2024 U.S. presidential election. (Joe Burns, Construction Dive)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
Amazon Can be Liable in Louisiana
August 05, 2024 —
Michael J. Ciamaichelo - The Subrogation StrategistIn June 2024, the Supreme Court of Louisiana held that: (1) Amazon can be considered a “seller” of defective products sold by third parties on its website; and (2) Amazon can be liable under a theory of negligent undertaking for third-party products. In Pickard v. Amazon.com, Inc., No. 2023-CQ-01596, 2024 La. LEXIS 1112, a Louisiana man, Archie Pickard, died from burns sustained in a house fire allegedly caused by a defective battery charger purchased on Amazon from a third-party seller located in China. Mr. Pickard’s family filed a lawsuit against Amazon in the United States District Court for the Western District of Louisiana alleging claims under the Louisiana Products Liability Act (LPLA) and for negligent undertaking. Amazon filed a motion for summary judgment, which prompted the federal court to certify questions to the Supreme Court of Louisiana regarding these two claims.
Amazon Can be a “Seller” Under the Louisiana Products Liability Act
Amazon does not neatly fit within the definition of “seller” under the LPLA because the LPLA was drafted in 1988, before the internet existed. The LPLA defines a “seller” as a person or entity (who is not the manufacturer) who conveys title or possession of the product to another for something of value. La R.S. 9.2800.53(s) (emphasis added). The Supreme Court of Louisiana determined that Amazon was a “seller” because it conveyed “possession” of the charger to Mr. Pickard through the “Fulfillment by Amazon” (FBA) program, which provides storage, delivery, customer service, and returns of third-party products sold on Amazon. Most products on Amazon are sold by third parties, rather than Amazon. Many third-party sellers are small or medium-size companies, and some are individuals seeking to make supplemental income. Amazon offers the FBA program to handle storage and logistics to third-party sellers. When a product is sold through the FBA program, the seller sends the product to Amazon’s warehouses, where it is stored until it is purchased. When an FBA-product is purchased, Amazon collects payment, delivers the product (often in an Amazon van), and handles the potential return of the product. The Supreme Court of Louisiana determined that Amazon was a “seller” of the battery charger even though Amazon did not pass title to Mr. Pickard because: (1) Amazon had physical custody of the charger while stored in the warehouse; and (2) Amazon controlled the transaction and logistics through its FBA program.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Michael J. Ciamaichelo, White and WilliamsMr. Ciamaichelo may be contacted at
ciamaichelom@whiteandwilliams.com
Timely and Properly Assert Affirmative Defenses and Understand Statutory Conditions Precedent
August 05, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesA recent case serves as a reminder to TIMELY and PROPERLY assert affirmative defenses and to understand statutory conditions precedent to construction lien claims. Failing to do one or the other could be severely detrimental to the position you want to take in a dispute, whether it is a lien foreclosure dispute, or any other dispute.
In Scherf v. Tom Krips Construction, Inc., 2024 WL 3297592 (Fla. 4th DCA 2024), the president of a construction company and his wife were building a residence. They orally accepted the proposal from the concrete shell contractor and asked for invoices to be submitted to the president’s construction company. No written contract was memorialized. The president and his wife did not pay the concrete shell contractor and the contractor recorded a lien and sued to foreclose on the lien. Years later (the case had been stayed because the president and his wife filed for bankruptcy and the shell contractor had to get leave of the automatic bankruptcy stay to pursue the lien foreclosure), the shell contractor moved for summary judgment. The president and his wife moved for leave to file an amended answer and affirmative defenses. They claimed the oral contract was with the construction company and the shell contractor was required to serve a Notice to Owner under
Florida Statute s. 713.06. Alternatively, they argued that if the oral contract was with the president and his wife, the shell contractor was required to serve a Final Contractor’s Payment Affidavit at least 5 days before filing its lien foreclosure claim, and did not, as required by s. 713.06.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
$31.5M Settlement Reached in Contract Dispute between Judlau and the Illinois Tollway
September 16, 2024 —
Annemarie Mannion - Engineering News-RecordThe Illinois Tollway will pay nearly $31.5 million to New York-based Judlau Contracting and its trade contractors to resolve a lawsuit filed after the tollway, in April, terminated a $324-million contract with Judlau to rebuild the southbound lanes of the Interstate 290 and Interstate 88 interchange near Oak Brook, Ill.
Reprinted courtesy of
Annemarie Mannion, Engineering News-Record
Ms. Mannion may be contacted at manniona@enr.com
Read the full story...
Insured Fails to Provide Adequate Proof of Water Damage Through Roof
December 10, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe federal district court granted the insurer's motion for summary judgment due on the insured's claims for water damage to a church. Unity Church of God in Christ of York v. Church Mutual Ins. Co., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 163204 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 11, 2024).
Unity Church alleged that it suffered a sudden and accidental direct physical loss to its church. Wind damage to the roof of the church allowed rainwater to leak into the sanctuary of the church. Notice was given to Church Mutual Insurance Company, but coverage was denied.
Unity Church filed suit alleging breach of contract. Church Mutual answered and asserted a counterclaim for a declaratory judgment that the water damage to the church was outside the policy's coverage because the damage was caused by rain. Church Mutual filed for summary judgment.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Ethical Limits on Preparing a Witness for Deposition or Trial
October 28, 2024 —
Stu Richeson - The Dispute ResolverIn this week’s blog post, we are going to take a brief look at ethical issues associated with preparing a witness for a deposition or to testify at trial. Most attorneys would agree that it is permissible to meet with a witness before the witness’s deposition to discuss what to expect. On the other hand, there is no question that advising a witness to provide false testimony would be improper. But what about the area in between those two extremes? For instance, can an attorney suggest to a witness how to phrase answers to anticipated questions that, while true, might not be the way the witness would have
Strangers in a Strange Land: Revisiting Arbitration Provisions to Account for Increasing International InfluencesNevada Construction Defect Lawyers Dead in Possible SuicidesNuclear Fusion Pushes to Reach Commercial Power Plant StageQuick Note: October 1, 2023 Changes to Florida’s Construction StatutesCongratulations to Partner Madeline Arcellana on Her Selection as a Top Rank Attorney in Nevada!How a Maryland County Created the Gold Standard for Building Emissions ReductionSummary Judgment Granted to Insurer for Hurricane DamageAssert a Party’s Noncompliance of Conditions Precedent with ParticularityICC/ASHRAE/USGBC/IES Green Model Code Integrates Existing StandardsHOA Foreclosure Excess Sale Proceeds Go to OwnerEx-Detroit Demolition Official Sentenced for Taking BribesAxa Unveils Plans to Transform ‘Stump’ Into London SkyscraperDaiwa House to Invest 150 Billion Yen in U.S. Rental HousingHow You Plead Allegations to Trigger Liability Insurer’s Duties Is CriticalFeds, County Seek Delay in Houston $7B Road Widening Over Community ImpactSupreme Court Addresses Newly Amended Statute of Repose for Construction ClaimsDenver Parking Garage Roof Collapses Crushing VehiclesBlackouts Require a New Look at Backup PowerDenial of Coverage For Bodily Injury After Policy Period Does Not Violate Public PolicyWill The New U.S.-Mexico-Canada Trade Deal Calm Industry Jitters?Water Bond Would Authorize $7.5 Billion for California Water Supply Infrastructure ProjectsTexas Supreme Court Declines to Waive Sovereign Immunity in Premises Defect CaseDon’t Fall in Trap of Buying the Cheapest Insurance Policy as it May be Bad for Your Business Risks and NeedsCongratulations to BWB&O Partner John Toohey and His Fellow Panel Members on Their Inclusion in West Coast Casualty’s 2022 Program!Haight Expands California Reach – Opens Office in SacramentoHousing Starts in U.S. Beat 1 Million Pace for Second MonthBe Careful in Contracting and BusinessConstruction Defects not Creating Problems for Bay BridgeSurety's Settlement Without Principal's Consent Is Not Bad FaithConstruction Law Client Alert: California Is One Step Closer to Prohibiting Type I Indemnity Agreements In Private Commercial ProjectsAGC’s 2024 Construction Outlook. Infrastructure is Bright but Office-Geddon is NotThe Expansion of Potential Liability of Construction Managers and ConsultantsNewmeyer & Dillion Attorneys Selected to Best Lawyers in America© Orange County and as Attorneys of the Year 2018Rattlesnake Bite Triggers Potential Liability for WalmartIn Florida, Component Parts of an Improvement to Real Property are Subject to the Statute of Repose for Products Liability ClaimsChicago Makes First Major Update to City's Building Code in 70 YearsRuling Closes the Loop on Restrictive Additional Insured Endorsement – Reasonable Expectations of Insured Builder Prevails Over Intent of InsurerHawaii Federal District Court Denies Title Insurer's Motion for Summary JudgmentCourt Clarifies Sequence in California’s SB800Tech to Help Contractors Avoid LitigationCGL Policy Covering Attorney’s Fees in Property Damage ClaimsThe “Your Work” Exclusion—Is there a Trend against Coverage?Elizabeth Lofts Condo Owners Settle with Plumbing SupplierNevada’s Changing Liability Insurance Landscape—State Insurance Regulator Issues Emergency Regulation and Guidance Addressing Controversial “Defense-Within-Limits” LegislationReservation of Rights Letter Merely Citing Policy Provisions InadequateSenior Housing Surplus Seen as Boomers Spur Building BoomTaylor Morrison v. Terracon and the Homeowner Protection Act of 2007Man Pleads Guilty in Construction Kickback SchemeFlying Solo: How it Helps My Construction ClientsWhite and Williams Earns Tier 1 Rankings from U.S. News "Best Law Firms" 2019“A No-Lose Proposition?”Building Supplier Sued for Late and Defective Building MaterialsHaight Brown & Bonesteel Attorneys Named Best Lawyers in America ® 2016Perrin Construction Defect Claims & Trial ConferenceConstruction Reaches Half-Way Point on San Diego's $2.1 Billion Mid-Coast TrolleyWill Superusers Future-Proof the AEC Industry?Carbon Monoxide Injuries Caused by One OccurrenceHHMR Celebrates 20 Years of Service!Bond Principal Necessary on a Mechanic’s Lien ClaimConstruction Defects Lead to Demolition of Seattle’s 25-story McGuire Apartments BuildingInsured's Failure to Prove Entire Collapse of Building Leads to DismissalSnooze You Lose? Enforcement of Notice and Timing ProvisionsOhio Condo Development Case Filed in 2011 is Scheduled for TrialSenate Overwhelmingly Passes Water Infrastructure BillGetting U.S to Zero Carbon Will Take a $2.5 Trillion Investment by 2030 
