Can Businesses Resolve Construction Disputes Outside of Court?
August 19, 2024 —
Scott L. Baker - Los Angeles Litigation BlogTime is of the essence in any construction project. So, if a dispute arises at any point, business owners generally wish to avoid the chance of a time-consuming case going to court.
Can California construction businesses
manage these disputes effectively outside of court? It is possible in some cases. Business owners should carefully consider these three steps.
1. Go Back to the Contract
Even if the contract is at the center of the dispute, it is important to refer to any details regarding dispute resolution included within the document. It is common for contracts to have some form of a dispute resolution clause. In such a case, both parties should follow the steps outlined in that agreement.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Scott L. Baker, Baker & AssociatesMr. Baker may be contacted at
slb@bakerslaw.com
Definitions Matter in Illinois: Tenant Held Liable Only for Damage to Apartment Unit
September 09, 2024 —
Gus Sara - The Subrogation StrategistIn Phila. Indem. Ins. Co. v. Gonzalez, No. 1-23-0833, 2024 Ill. App. Unpub. LEXIS 1372, the Appellate Court of Illinois considered whether the terms of a lease agreement limited a tenant’s liability for fire damages, a fire caused by her negligence, to her apartment unit only. The plaintiff insured the subject apartment building, which incurred damage to several units as result of a fire in the tenant’s unit. The lease defined “Premises” as the specific apartment unit occupied by the tenant and held the tenant responsible for damage caused to the Premises. While the court found that the lease permitted the plaintiff to subrogate against the tenant, it held that the lease terms limited the damages to the tenant’s apartment unit only.
In Gonzalez, the plaintiff’s insured owned a multi-unit apartment building in Chicago. In September 2019, the building owner entered into a lease agreement with the defendant for apartment Unit 601. The lease stated that Unit 601 was the “Leased Address (Premises).” Another provision stated that building owner “hereby leases to Tenant(s) and Tenant(s) hereby leases from Landlord(s) for use as a private dwelling only, the Premises, together with the fixtures and appliances (if any) in the premises…” The lease also stated that “Tenant shall be liable for any damage done to the premises as a result of Tenant’s or Tenant’s invitees, guests or others authorized to reside in the Premises [sic] direct action, negligence, or failure to inform Landlord of repairs necessary to prevent damage to the Premises.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gus Sara, White and WilliamsMr. Sara may be contacted at
sarag@whiteandwilliams.com
Toolbox Talk Series Recap - Guided Choice Mediation
November 05, 2024 —
Douglas J. Mackin - The Dispute ResolverIn the September 26, 2024 edition of Division 1's Toolbox Talk Series,
Clifford Shapiro presented on Guided Choice Mediation (“GCM”) and how it can lead to better outcomes in construction disputes.
GCM is an approach to mediation that focuses on early and efficient dispute resolution, which prominent mediators created as a public interest project.
Shapiro described his particular variant of GCM based on his experience while acknowledging that other Guided Choice Mediators’ processes may differ from his in various ways. Shapiro’s brand of GCM focuses on ensuring that parties have reasonable expectations and appropriate settlement authority prior to arriving at a mediation. Some of the strategies to help accomplish these noble goals are (i) early mediator engagement, (ii) mediator facilitation of information exchange, (iii) mediator involvement with insurance issues (particularly important in construction defect cases, especially those with multiple defendants), (iii) pre-mediation ex parte meetings, and (iv) mediator participation in risk analysis. These strategies are not typical in the more traditional/historic approach to mediation in which mediation is scheduled based on a scheduling order, mediation statements are sent to the mediator roughly a week before the scheduled mediation (and sometimes not even shared with anyone other than the mediator), and the parties speak with the mediator for the first time on the day of the mediation.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Douglas J. Mackin, Cozen O’ConnorMr. Mackin may be contacted at
dmackin@cozen.com
Nuclear Energy Gets a Much-Needed Boost
August 05, 2024 —
The Editorial Board - BloombergPresident Joe Biden, as you’ve no doubt heard, has had a rough few weeks. Yet on Tuesday, he signed a bill into law that could well prove transformative for America’s energy future. Here’s hoping — whatever happens in November’s election — that more progress lies ahead.
Known as the Advance Act, the bill seeks to remedy some long-standing flaws in nuclear-energy regulation. To reach net zero, the world will need to roughly double its nuclear capacity by 2050, according to the International Energy Agency. Yet constructing new nuclear plants in the US is expensive, time-consuming and encumbered by red tape. Partly as a result, the industry has stagnated: The share of electricity generated by nuclear is projected to decline to about 12% by 2050, from about 18% today.
The Advance Act should help reverse that trend. As a start, it makes useful reforms to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, allowing the agency to hire more staff, reduce licensing fees, speed application processing and ease the burden of environmental reviews. It also makes a small but consequential change to the commission’s mission, requiring it — after decades of focusing on potential threats — to also consider the vast public benefits of nuclear energy when making regulatory decisions.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
The Editorial Board, Bloomberg
Las Vegas Stadium for Athletics, Now $1.75B Project, Gains Key OK
December 31, 2024 —
Doug Puppel - Engineering News RecordConstruction start of a new stadium in Las Vegas to host the former Oakland, Calif.-based Athletics Major League Baseball team gained a key approval on Dec. 5, with the municipal stadium authority unanimously greenlighting the now $1.75-billion facility.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Doug Puppel, ENR
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (8/14/24) – Commercial Real Estate AI, Hotel Pipeline Growth, and Housing Market Improvements
September 23, 2024 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, nonresidential spending drops, realtor payment structure changes, office vacancy rates soar, and more!
- A decline in mortgage rates and a drop in housing prices are giving buyers a potential path to securing homeownership. (Omar Mohammed, Newsweek)
- Starting August 17, new rules will roll out that overhaul the way Realtors get paid to help people buy and sell their homes. (Samantha Delouya, CNN)
- Spending dropped in almost half of nonresidential subcategories in June with the decrease stemming from higher interest rates, tighter credit conditions and a softening economy. (Sebastian Obando, Construction Dive)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
Policy's One Year Suit Limitation Does Not Apply to Challenging the Insurer's Claims Handling
October 07, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe California Supreme Court held that the policy's suit limitation of one year, consistent with the statute requiring suit be file within twelve months after a loss, did not apply to claims alleging violation of the state's unfair competition law (UCL). Rosenberg-Wohl v. State Farm Fire and Cas. Co., 2024 Cal. LEXIS 3806 (Cal. July 18, 2024).
Plaintiff held a homeowners policy issued by State Farm that provided coverage for all risks except those specifically excluded under the policy. The suit limitation provision provided, "Suit Against Us. No action shall be brought unless there has been compliance with the policy provision.The action must be started within one year after the date of loss or damage."
On two occasions in late 2018 or early 2019, plaintiff's neighbor stumble and fell as she descended a staircase at plaintiff's residence. Plaintiff discovered that the pitch of the stairs had changed, and replacement of the stairs was required to fix the issue. She contacted State Farm on or around April 23, 2019. On August 9, 2019, plaintiff submitted a claim to State Farm, seeking reimbursement for what she paid to repair the staircase. State Farm denied the claim, advising there was no coverage and identifying several exclusions as potentially applicable.
Read the full stor
Court of Appeals Discusses Implied Duty of Good Faith and Fair Dealing in Public Works ContractingSanctions of $1.6 Million Plus Imposed on Contractor for Fabricating Evidence20 Years of BHA at West Coast Casualty's CD Seminar: Chronicling BHA's Innovative ExhibitsBreach Of Duty of Good Faith And Fair Dealing Packaged With Contract Disputes Act ClaimInsurer Not Entitled to Summary Judgment on Construction Defect ClaimsAppraisal Ordered After Carrier Finds Loss Even if Cause DisputedRoni Most, Esq., Reappointed as a City of Houston Associate JudgeHow Technology Reduces the Risk of Façade DefectsToll Brothers Honored at the Shore Builders Association of Central New Jersey AwardsSouth Dakota Supreme Court Holds That Faulty Workmanship Constitutes an “Occurrence”Big Data Meets Big Green: Data Centers and Carbon Removal Compete for Zero-Emission EnergyConstruction Employment Rose in 38 States from 2013 to 2014Did the Court of Appeals Just Raise the Bar for California Contractors to Self-Report Construction-Related Judgments?National Engineering and Public Works Roadshow Highlights Low Battery Seawall Restoration Project in CharlestonFirst-Party Statutory Bad Faith – 60 Days to Cure Means 60 Days to CureColorado’s Federal District Court Finds Carriers Have Joint and Several Defense DutiesVirtual Jury Trials of Construction Disputes: The Necessary Union of Both Sides of the BrainPredicting the Future of Texas’s Grid Is a Texas-Sized ChallengeMassive Redesign Turns Newark Airport Terminal Into a Foodie Theme ParkReport to Congress Calls for Framework to Cut Post-Quake Recovery TimeGeorgia Court of Appeals Holds That Policyholder Can “Stack” the Limits of Each Primary Policy After Asbestos ClaimSan Francisco Museum Nears $610 Million Fundraising GoalKnow Your Obligations Under Both the Prime Contract and SubcontractThree's a Trend: Second, Fourth and Ninth Circuits Uphold Broad "Related Claims" LanguageInsurer Must Defend Claims of Alleged Willful Coal RemovalApartments pushed up US homebuilding in SeptemberQuick Note: Be Careful with Pay if Paid Clauses (Both Subcontractors and General Contractors)Colorado HB 13-1090: Concerning Payment of Amounts Due Under a Construction Agreement“Wait! Do You Have All Your Ducks in a Row?” Filing of a Certificate of Merit in Conjunction With a ComplaintAppellate Court Endorses Discretionary Test for Vicarious Disqualification of Law Firms Due To New Attorney’s ConflictEliminating Waste in Construction – An Interview with Turner BurtonD.C. Decision Finding No “Direct Physical Loss” for COVID-19 Closures Is Not Without Severe LimitationsFewer NYC Construction Deaths as Safety Law Awaits Governor's SignatureHow Long does a Florida Condo Association Have to File a Construction Defect Claim?McCarthy Workers Test Fall-Protection Harnesses Designed to Better Fit WomenNo Choice between Homeowner Protection and Bankrupt Developers?Allegations Confirm Duty to Defend Construction Defect ClaimsLargest Per Unit Settlement Ever in California Construction Defect Case?Supreme Court of New Jersey Reviews Statutes of Limitation and the Discovery Rule in Construction Defect CasesBidders Shortlisted as Oroville Dam Work Schedule is SetConstruction Client Advisory: The Power of the Bonded Stop Notice Extends to Expended Construction FundsPolicy Reformed to Add New Building Owner as Additional InsuredUS Court Questions 102-Mile Transmission Project Over River CrossingCourt Holds That Parent Corporation Lacks Standing to Sue Subsidiary’s Insurers for Declaratory ReliefHunton’s Alice Weeks Selected to the Miami Dade Bar’s Circle of Excellence for Insurance LitigationHandling Construction Defect Claims – New Edition ReleasedAutomating Your Home? There’s an App for ThatTexas and Georgia Are Paying the Price for SprawlWhy Employees Are Taking Ownership of Their Architecture FirmsContractor Prevails on Summary Judgment To Establish Coverage under Subcontractor's PolicyWall Street Journal Analyzes the Housing Market DirectionMontana Significantly Revises Its Product Liability LawsConstruction Insurance Costs for New York Schools is Going Up"Your Work" Exclusion Bars Coverage for Contractor's Faulty WorkmanshipNancy Conrad to Serve as President of the Pennsylvania Bar AssociationBlackstone Suffers Court Setback in Irish Real Estate DramaContractor Sues License BoardU.S. Navy Sailors Sue Tokyo Utility Company Over Radiation PoisoningThird Circuit Follows Pennsylvania Law - Damage Caused by Faulty Workmanship Does Not Arise from an OccurrenceDiscussion of the Discovery Rule and Tolling Statute of LimitationsClient Alert: Restaurant Owed Duty of Care to Driver Killed by Third-Party on Street Adjacent to Restaurant Parking LotRecovering Time and Costs from Hurricane Helene: Force Majeure Solutions for ContractorsNorth Carolina Weakened Its Building Codes in 2013Gone Fishing: Tenant’s Insurer Casts A Line Seeking To Subrogate Against The LandlordMassive Wildfire Near Boulder, Colo., Destroys Nearly 1,000 Homes and BusinessesInsurer's Late Notice Defense Fails on Summary Judgment 
