“It Just Didn’t Add Up!”
November 05, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - LexologyOverturning arbitration awards in court is difficult. One of the few bases for a challenge to an award (under the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. 10(a)(4), as well as most state arbitration laws) is where the arbitrator is alleged to have “exceeded [his/her] powers” afforded the arbitrator by whatever rules and agreements are in place for the arbitration. Obviously, this places a burden on the arbitrator to “color within the lines” when serving as arbitrator and issuing rulings in the case.
“After extensive discovery and a 10-day hearing, the Tribunal rendered a 142-page” award, whereupon the parties both sought to have the arbitrators correct what the parties agreed was an error in the award – increasing the award by $47,710. One of the parties, however, went further, urging that the arbitrators “erroneously included damages for claims related to production revenue” that occurred before a certain date. According to the court, that party was urging that “the Tribunal erred by factoring into its award damages related to Claims 2 and 3, which the Tribunal never substantially addressed.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
Staffing Company Not Entitled to Make a Claim Against a Payment Bond and Attorneys’ Fees on State Public Works Payment Bonds
August 12, 2024 —
Garret Murai - California Construction Law BlogIt’s not quite Baskin Robbin’s “31 Flavors” but the panoply of statutory construction payment remedies available to contractors, subcontractor and material suppliers in California, from mechanics liens to stop payment notices to payment bond claims, can be tempting to reach for when you are not paid. However, some flavors are more readily available than others, as a staffing agency discovered in
K & S Staffing Solutions, Inc. v. The Western Surety Company, Case Nos. C096705 and C097987 (January 2, 2024).
The K & S Staffing Case
The California Department of Transportation awarded VSS International, Inc. two public works construction contracts for road maintenance. Each involved an expenditure of over $25,000 and VSSI obtained a payment bond from Western Surety Company.
Titan DVBE Inc. was a subcontractor on both projects. For most years, Titan employed its own workers. However, when it learned that its insurance carrier would no longer be offering workers’ compensation insurance in California it switched to K & S Staffing Solutions, Inc. to fulfill its staffing needs.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Garret Murai, Nomos LLPMr. Murai may be contacted at
gmurai@nomosllp.com
A Place to Study Eternity: Building the Giant Magellan Telescope
October 15, 2024 —
Jeff Rubenstone - Engineering News-RecordSituated on a remote mountaintop in the Atacama Desert in Chile, the Giant Magellan Telescope will one day allow astronomers to peer further into the universe with a greater degree of clarity than ever before. But siting a highly sensitive instrument with seven massive, 8.4-meter-dia mirrors on a windy peak in one of the world’s most seismically active regions takes careful engineering, especially since the 12-story upper section of the 22-story telescope enclosure will have to rotate 360° with an extreme degree of precision, multiple times a night.
Reprinted courtesy of
Jeff Rubenstone, Engineering News-Record
Mr. Rubenstone may be contacted at rubenstonej@enr.com
Read the full story...
Do You Have the Receipt? Pennsylvania Court Finds Insufficient Evidence That Defendant Sold the Product
December 23, 2024 —
Gus Sara - The Subrogation StrategistIn State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Coway USA, Inc., No. 22-cv-3516, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 192849, the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania (District Court) considered whether the plaintiff produced sufficient evidence to establish that the defendant sold and/or marketed a product and, thus, could be held liable for an alleged defect in the product. The plaintiff, a subrogating insurance carrier, brought strict product liability and breach of warranty claims against the defendant—the installer of a bidet in its insured’s home—claiming that the defendant also marketed and sold the bidet. The sole evidence to support a finding that the defendant sold the bidet was the homeowner’s testimony that she bought the product from the installer. The court found that the insured’s testimony, without any documentation or other corroborating evidence, was insufficient to establish that the defendant sold the product. Since proof of a sale is a required element for strict product liability and breach of warranty claims, the District Court granted the defendant’s motion for summary judgment, dismissing the case.
This case involved a water loss to the Pennsylvania residence of Mikyung Kim and her husband Adrian Kim (collectively, the Kims) that was discovered in April 2021. An investigation revealed that the water loss originated from the failure of a bidet for a toilet in the second-floor bathroom. The Kims alleged that defendant, Coway USA, Inc. (Coway), sold the bidet and installed it around 2010. An employee of the plaintiff’s liability expert, a materials engineer, opined that a T-connector—a plastic valve that regulates the flow of water to and through the bidet—failed due to overtightening of the connector during the manufacturing process.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gus Sara, White and WilliamsMr. Sara may be contacted at
sarag@whiteandwilliams.com
With Historic Removal of Four Dams, Klamath River Flows Again Unhindered
October 21, 2024 —
Tim Newcomb - Engineering News-RecordIn a period of 16 months, four dams built between 1903 and 1962 came down as part of a monumental effort to clear 35 miles of the Klamath River spanning Oregon and California. The project owner, the Klamath River Renewal Corp., describes it as the largest dam removal effort in U.S.—and possibly world—history.
Reprinted courtesy of
Tim Newcomb, Engineering News-Record
ENR may be contacted at enr@enr.com
Read the full story...
Corrective Action Protest Grounds for GSA Schedule Federal Construction Contractors
September 09, 2024 —
Marissa L. Downs - The Dispute ResolverA contract awarded, protested, terminated, appealed, then reinstated. It’s no secret that federal construction procurements are plagued with uncertainty. From delays, constructive suspensions, compromised supply chains, the litigation-laden critical path method, and the mandate for all construction materials used in federally funded projects for infrastructure to be produced in the United States under the Build America, Buy America Act (BABAA) (to name just a few traditional and emerging favorites), just one of these issues could fill the rest of anyone’s month with substantive research. To add one more, which is entirely unique to bid protests, federal contractors–including construction contractors–listed in a General Service Administration (GSA) Schedule may have new grounds to have a contract award reinstated that was terminated by a federal agency pending a GAO decision.
GAO Protest
An initial GAO protest filed by Deloitte & Touche LLP (Deloitte) argued that the National Geo-Spatial Intelligence Agency (Agency) wrongfully made an award to Kearney & Company, P.C. (Kearney) when the Agency: (1) improperly evaluated quotes; and (2) failed to conduct a proper best-value tradeoff analysis. At issue was a competed task order with Kearney under a GSA FSS multiple-award contract. Before the GAO issued an opinion, however, it held an unrecorded predictive-outcome conference with Deloitte and Kearney where the only mutual consensus was the likely ineligibility of all offerors for the relevant award. The Agency subsequently elected to take corrective action, terminating Kearney’s contract award for convenience, amending the solicitation to avoid issues (including undisputed issues) addressed in the GAO protest. After the Agency adopted their corrective action, the GAO protest was dismissed as academic and moot.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Marissa L. Downs, Laurie & Brennan, LLPMs. Downs may be contacted at
mdowns@lauriebrennan.com
FEMA Offers Recovery Tips for California Wildfire Survivors
January 14, 2025 —
FEMAWASHINGTON -- While fire suppression activities are still ongoing in parts of Southern California, affected individuals and families are taking steps toward recovery.
FEMA is helping people jumpstart their recovery. You may be eligible for FEMA assistance, even if you have insurance. More than $5.3 million so far are in the hands of survivors to help pay for emergency supplies like food, water and baby formula as well as to replace personal property and pay for a temporary place to stay. Below are tips to help Californians recover from the historic wildfires.
If your primary home was affected by the fires, FEMA may be able to help you cover certain costs – like paying for essential items, finding a place to stay, replacing personal property or making basic repairs to your home. However, FEMA assistance is designed to help you if you do not have insurance or if your insurance policies don't cover basic needs. If you have insurance, you should file a claim as soon as possible and be ready to provide your coverage information when applying to FEMA.
There are several ways to apply for FEMA assistance:
To view an accessible video about how to apply visit:
FEMA Accessible: Registering for Individual Assistance or
en Español.
Mitigating Mold Exposure in Manufacturing and Multifamily Buildings
July 31, 2024 —
Laura Champagne - Construction ExecutiveAs hurricanes season and summer storms approach, more apartment complexes, commercial and industrial properties, and public buildings are at risk of leaking and flooding. Water-saturated structures are prime breeding grounds for mold, but there are ways to prevent, detect and remove it before it becomes a serious and costly issue—for buildings and building residents alike. Being proactive limits an owner’s exposure to the liability of debilitating health effects and structural safety concerns.
Mold requires three things to grow: water, food and humidity. Water will stealthily penetrate small porous surfaces of any building material, such as drywall, plaster, wood, c
Incorporation, Indemnity and Statutes of Limitations, Oh My!Coverage for Collapse Ordered on Summary JudgmentUsed French Fry Oil Fuels London Offices as Buildings Go GreenRachel Reynolds Selected as Prime Member of ADTABuilders Can’t Rely on SB800Taylor Morrison Home Corp’ New San Jose DevelopmentBad Faith in the First Party Insurance ContextNew York Court Temporarily Enjoins UCC Foreclosure SaleDeescalating Hyper EscalationRecent Opinions Clarify Enforceability of Pay-if-Paid Provisions in Construction ContractsBuffalo-Area Roof Collapses Threaten Lives, Businesses After Historic SnowfallIs an Initial Decision Maker, Project Neutral, or Dispute Resolution Board Right for You?A Court-Side Seat: Flint Failures, Missed Deadlines, Toad Work and a Game of ChickenOSHA Finalizes Rule on Crane Operator Qualification and CertificationCourt of Appeals Discusses the Difference Between “Claims-Made” and “Occurrence-Based” Insurance PoliciesContract’s Definition of “Substantial Completion” Does Not Apply to Third Party for Purposes of SOL, Holds Court of AppealResidential Interior Decorator Was Entitled to Lien and Was Not Engaging in Unlicensed ContractingUnesco Denies Claim It Cleared Construction of Zambezi DamJudicial Economy Disfavors Enforcement of Mandatory Forum Selection ClauseSchool District Client Advisory: Civility is not an Option, It is a DutyMaine Case Demonstrates High Risk for Buying Home “As Is”Timber Prices Likely to Keep Rising140 Days Until The California Consumer Privacy Act Becomes Law - Why Aren't More Businesses Complying?Connecticut Court Clarifies Construction CoverageCourt Bars Licensed Contractor From Seeking Compensation for Work Performed by Unlicensed Sub Anthony Garasi, Jared Christensen and August Hotchkin are Recognized as Nevada Legal EliteLook Out! Texas Building Shedding Marble PanelsHomeowner’s Policy Excludes Coverage for Loss Caused by Chinese DrywallNevada Update: Nevada Commissioner of Insurance Updates Burning Limits Statute with Emergency RegulationDevelopment in CBF Green Building Case in Maryland$24 Million Verdict Against Material Supplier Overturned Where Plaintiff Failed To Prove Supplier’s Negligence Or Breach Of Contract Caused A SB800 ViolationParis ‘Locks of Love’ Overload Bridges, Threatening StructuresHome Construction Thriving in LubbockLook to West Africa for the Future of Green ArchitectureTraub Lieberman Attorneys Jessica Burtnett and Jessica Kull Obtain Dismissal of Claim Against Insurance Producer Based Upon Statute of LimitationsConstruction Defect Leads to Death of WorkerAccident/Occurrence Requirement Does not Preclude Coverage for Vicarious Liability or Negligent SupervisionHunton Insurance Coverage Partner Lawrence J. Bracken II Awarded Emory Public Interest Committee’s 2024 Lifetime Commitment to Public Service AwardDOI Aims to Modernize its “Inefficient and Inflexible” Type A Natural Resource Damages Assessment RegulationsDocumentation Important for Defending Construction Defect ClaimsSeven Coats Rose Attorneys Named to Texas Rising Stars ListCompanies Move to Houston Area and Spur Home BuildingConstruction Litigation Roundup: “I Never Had a Chance”A Court-Side Seat: “Inholdings” Upheld, a Pecos Bill Come Due and Agency Actions AboundFeds OK $9B Houston Highway Project After Two-Year PauseThe Future of Construction Tech Is Decision TechDon’t Just Document- Document Right!Statutory Time Limits for Construction Defects in MassachusettsKnow When Your Claim “Accrues” or Risk Losing ItPennsylvania Superior Court Tightens Requirements for Co-Worker Affidavits in Asbestos CasesNinth Circuit Resolves Federal-State Court Split Regarding Whether 'Latent' Defects Discovered After Duration of Warranty Period are Actionable under California's Lemon Law StatuteFine Art Losses – “Canvas” the Subrogation LandscapeAs Fracture Questions Remain, Team Raced to Save Mississippi River BridgeGOP, States, Industry Challenge EPA Project Water Impact RuleDeveloper Pre-Conditions in CC&Rs Limiting Ability of HOA to Make Construction Defect Claims, Found UnenforceableProperty Owner’s Defense Goes Up in Smoke in Careless Smoking CaseBP Is Not an Additional Insured Under Transocean's Policy 
