When Licensing Lapses: How One Contractor Lost a $1 Million Dispute
October 28, 2024 —
Matthew DeVries - Best Practices Construction LawAs a construction lawyer, contractor licensing is a very key aspect of my practice. This can include new contractor applications, increase or changes in monetary limits or license classifications, change in ownership or qualifying agent , and, of course, licensing violations.
The recent decision in Incident365 Florida, LLC v. Ocean Pointe V Condominium Association serves as an important reminder for general contractors and subcontractors regarding the significance of proper licensing and thorough contract review in disaster recovery and construction services.
Case Overview
In this case, Incident365 Florida, LLC entered into disaster recovery agreements with several condominium associations (“Associations”) following Hurricane Irma. The agreements involved various tasks such as water damage mitigation, dehumidification, and the removal of unsalvageable materials. However, Incident365 lacked the appropriate contractor’s license when performing the work, which became a focal point in the dispute when the Associations refused to pay the remaining balance of $1 million, citing the absence of the required licensure.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Matthew DeVries, BuchalterMr. DeVries may be contacted at
mdevries@buchalter.com
Deferred Maintenance?
December 17, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - LexologyA Tennessee-based “outsourced maintenance vendor” to an engine company filed suit in Louisiana state court seeking to recover nearly $150,000 on “open account,” for work previously performed. The engine company removed the case to the Federal District Court in New Orleans and asserted as a defense that the vendor lacked a proper Louisiana construction contractor’s license. The engine company filed a motion for summary judgment based on the defense.
Under Louisiana law, a contract between parties is “absolutely null”--considered to have never existed--where one of the parties performed services without a required Louisiana contractor’s license, and the combined work reaches a $50,000 threshold. The engine company asserted that the vendor performed typical construction contractor work, including plywood flooring, applied epoxy to concrete flooring, erected part of a commercial carport, undertook certain heavy demolition, and installed fences, guardrails, and wire racks.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
California Supreme Court Finds Vertical Exhaustion Applies to First-Level Excess Policies
August 26, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiAddressing issues left open in its seminal decision in Montrose, the California Supreme Court found that the language in the first-level excess policies meant that the insured could access the policies upon exhaustion of the directly underlying policies purchased for the same policy period. Truck Ins. Exchange v. Kaiser Cement & Gypsum Corp., 2024 Cal. LEXIS 3271 (Cal. June 17, 2024).
From 1944 through the 1970's, Kaiser manufactured asbestos-containing products at numerous different facilities. By 2004, more than 24,000 claimants had filed product liability claims against Kaiser alleging that they had suffered bodily injury as a result of exposure to Kaiser's asbestos products. Kaiser tendered these claims to Truck, one of several primary insurers that had issued CGL policies to Kaiser.
In 2001, Truck initiated this coverage action to determine its indemnity and defense obligations to Kaiser. Truck later amended its complaint to add a cause of action for contribution against several of Kaiser's excess insurers. The issue presently before the court was whether Truck was entitled to contribution from various coinsurers that issued first-level excess policies to Kaiser during the period in question.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (7/2/24) – Increase in Commercial Property Vacancy Rates, Trouble for the Real Estate Market and Real Estate as a Long-Term Investment
July 31, 2024 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, the evolution of stadium construction, an increase in legal and legislative action affecting the multifamily sector, and growing concerns for owners of office space.
- The work-from-home trend will likely push up the commercial property vacancy rate in 2026 to a peak average of 24%, or 4 percentage points higher than the first quarter of this year. (Jim Tyson, CFO Dive)
- In recent years, stadium construction has evolved to focus more on cultivating the game day experience with some multibillion-dollar projects breaking ground, as existing venues get renovations. (Zachary Phillips, Construction Dive)
- A number of prominent issues affecting the multifamily industry, including rent control, fees and antitrust concerns, have been subject to increasing levels of legal and legislative action over the past year. (Mary Salmonsen, Multifamily Dive)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
Why Being Climate ‘Positive’ Is the Buzzy New Goal of Green Building
December 10, 2024 —
Olivia Rudgard - BloombergThe three buildings, dotted around Norway, couldn’t look more different: a soaring timber-and-concrete obelisk in Porsgrunn; a squat, two-story Montessori school on the edge of a forest in Drøbak; and a concrete and glass wedge-shaped office in Trondheim, just a few hundred miles from the edge of the
Arctic Circle. But they share a distinctive feature. Each has a roof perfectly tilted to squeeze out every possible drop of solar energy.
They are called
Powerhouses, and the initiative behind them claims they are all “energy positive”: The upfront energy “cost” of each building, and that of later demolition and disposal, is expected to be made back over the building’s lifetime. Powerhouses sometimes draw from the grid, especially in winter, but in the long Nordic summer days they give back many times over, overspilling excess solar energy into surrounding homes and businesses.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Olivia Rudgard, Bloomberg
Benefit of the Coblentz Agreement and Consent Judgment
August 26, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesIf you are not familiar with the concept of what is commonly known as a Coblentz agreement relative to an insurance coverage dispute, review these prior postings (
here and
here and
here). This is a good-to-know agreement if you are a claimant and need to consider an avenue of collection if the insured’s carrier denies coverage out of the gate (meaning the carrier has denied both the duty to defend and the duty to indemnify).
A recent Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals opinion demonstrates the Coblentz agreement concept. In Barrs v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co., 2024 WL 3673089 (11th Cir. 2024), an owner asserted a construction defect claim against its contractor. The owner hired the contractor to deconstruct a building and the contractor hired a demolition subcontractor. The owner noticed work was not being performed and materials (e.g., lumber) were missing; the demolition subcontractor had stolen materials. The subcontractor was terminated, and the owner claimed the contractor’s negligence allowed the theft and delayed his project. The contractor’s commercial general liability (CGL) insurer notified the insured-contractor that coverage did not exist and refused to defend the contractor. The owner sued the contractor under various theories of liability. The owner and contractor entered into a settlement agreement (i.e., the Coblentz agreement) where the contractor “admitted liability in the amount of $557,500.00….A consent judgment was entered against [the contractor] that closely tracked the settlement agreement but did not indicate which portion of the damages award was attributed to which claims. The agreement also assigned [owner] and all of [the contractor’s] rights to claim coverage and to recover available funds under [the contractor’s CGL policy].”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Toolbox Talk Series Recap - Guided Choice Mediation
November 05, 2024 —
Douglas J. Mackin - The Dispute ResolverIn the September 26, 2024 edition of Division 1's Toolbox Talk Series,
Clifford Shapiro presented on Guided Choice Mediation (“GCM”) and how it can lead to better outcomes in construction disputes.
GCM is an approach to mediation that focuses on early and efficient dispute resolution, which prominent mediators created as a public interest project.
Shapiro described his particular variant of GCM based on his experience while acknowledging that other Guided Choice Mediators’ processes may differ from his in various ways. Shapiro’s brand of GCM focuses on ensuring that parties have reasonable expectations and appropriate settlement authority prior to arriving at a mediation. Some of the strategies to help accomplish these noble goals are (i) early mediator engagement, (ii) mediator facilitation of information exchange, (iii) mediator involvement with insurance issues (particularly important in construction defect cases, especially those with multiple defendants), (iii) pre-mediation ex parte meetings, and (iv) mediator participation in risk analysis. These strategies are not typical in the more traditional/historic approach to mediation in which mediation is scheduled based on a scheduling order, mediation statements are sent to the mediator roughly a week before the
Courts Take Another Swipe at the Implied Warranty of the Plans and SpecificationsRenee Mortimer Recognized as "Defense Lawyer of the Year" by DTCICalifornia Supreme Court Endorses City Authority to Adopt Inclusionary Housing OrdinanceHistory and Gentrification Clash in a Gilded Age ResortResulting Loss From Faulty Workmanship CoveredMillion-Dollar U.S. Housing Loans Surge to Record LevelBWB&O’s Los Angeles Partner Eileen Gaisford and Associate Kelsey Kohnen Win a Motion for Terminating Sanctions!Courthouse Reporter Series: The Bizarre Case That Required a 117-Year-Old ExpertChimney Collapses at South African Utility’s Unfinished $13 Billion Power PlantN.J. Voters Approve $116 Million in School ConstructionDesign Firm Settles over Construction Defect ClaimPresenting a “Total Time” Delay Claim Is Not SufficientLake Charles Tower’s Window Damage Perplexes EngineersDraft Federal Legislation Reinforces Advice to Promptly Notify Insurers of COVID-19 LossesThe Rise Of The Improper P2P TacticBest Practices for ESI Collection in Construction LitigationThe Miller Act ExplainedInsurers Get “Floored” by Court of Appeals Regar
Why Metro Atlanta Is the Poster Child for the US Housing Crisis
Renovation Makes Old Arena Feel Brand New
Bert L. Howe & Associates Brings Professional Development Series to Their Houston Office
$24 Million Verdict Against Material Supplier Overturned Where Plaintiff Failed to Prove Supplier’s Negligence or Breach of Contract Caused an SB800 Violation
Litigation Privilege Saves the Day for Mechanic’s Liens
First Trump Agenda Nuggets Hit Construction
Balestreri Potocki & Holmes Attorneys Named 2020 Super Lawyers and Rising Star
There Are Consequences to Executed Documents Such as the Accord and Satisfaction Defense
Court Rules Planned Development of Banning Ranch May Proceed
Is the Issuance of a City Use Permit Referable? Not When It Is an Administrative Act
OSHA Releases COVID-19 Guidance
Professional Services Exclusion Bars Coverage Where Ordinary Negligence is Inseparably Intertwined With Professional Service
Beyond the Disneyland Resort: Special Events
Blackstone Said in $1.7 Billion Deal to Buy Apartments
Acceptable Worksite: New City of Seattle Specification Provisions Now In Effect
More Business Value from Drones with Propeller and Trimble – Interview with Rory San Miguel
Call Me Maybe? . . . Don’t Waive Your Rights Under the Right to Repair Act’s Prelitigation Procedures
Keep It Simple: Summarize (Voluminous Evidence, That Is...)
Real Estate Trends: Looking Ahead to 2021
Unbilled Costs Remain in Tutor Perini's Finances
White and Williams Earns Tier 1 Rankings from U.S. News "Best Law Firms" 2017
Kahana Feld Named to the Orange County Register 2024 Top Workplaces List
Implementation of CA Building Energy Efficiency Standards Delayed
CA Homeowners Challenging Alternate Pre-Litigation Procedures
The Black Woman Architect Who Hopes to Change the Face of Design in America
EPA Fines Ivory Homes for Storm Water Pollution
Trade Contract Revisions to Address COVID-19
Washington Supreme Court Finds Agent’s Representations in Certificate of Insurance Bind Insurance Company to Additional Insured Coverage
NYC-N.J. Gateway Rail-Tunnel Work May Start in 2023
Changes and Extra Work – Is There a Limit?
Are Defense Costs In Addition to Policy Limits?
Construction Litigation Roundup: “Indeed, You Just Design ‘Em”
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (1/24/24) – Long-Term Housing Issues in Hawaii, Underperforming REITs, and Growth in a Subset of the Hotel Sector
No Jail Time for Disbarred Construction Defect Lawyer
Five-Year Peak for Available Construction Jobs
A Lack of Sophistication With the Construction Contract Can Play Out In an Ugly Dispute
Colorado’s Workers’ Compensation Act and the Construction Industry
Home Prices Up, Inventory Down
Potential Extension of the Statutes of Limitation and Repose for Colorado Construction Defect Claims
Admissibility of Expert Opinions in Insurance Bad Faith Trials
Virginia Decision Emphasizes Importance of Naming All Necessary Parties
Damage Control: Major Rebuilds After Major Weather Events
GSA Releases Updated Standards to Accelerate Federal Buildings Toward Zero Emissions
10 Safety Tips for General Contractors
Colorado House Bill 19-1170: Undefined Levels of Mold or Dampness Can Make a Leased Residential Premises Uninhabitable
Spencer Mayer Receives Miami-Dade Bar Association's '40 Under 40' Award
Learning from Production Homes of the Past
Business Interruption, Food Spoilage Claims Resulting from Off Premise Power Failure Denied
CISA Clarifies – Construction is Part of Critical Infrastructure Activities
The National Building Museum’s A-Mazing Showpiece
